Keystone Mills Products for Sale

Store Locator

Stop by our store to see all that we have to offer.

Our store hours are:

Monday – Friday   7:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Saturday                8:00 AM – 11:30 AM

Sunday                         ~ Closed ~

Or visit one of our wholesale dealers listed below.


Keystone Mills
1975 Rt 336
Romulus, NY 14541
315-549-8226

A.H. Wilcox & Son, Inc
212 South Main Street
Naples N.Y. 14512
585-374-2580

Albert Miller
6130 CR 18
West Edmeston N.Y. 13485
.

Andre & Son Inc.
17150 State Route 706
Montrose P.A. 18801
570-278-1131

Banfield- Baker Corp.
2512 Corning Road
Horseheads N.Y. 14845
607-739-8771

Bear Gulch Farm Store
683 Bear Gulch Road
Richmondville N.Y. 12149
518-231-2588

Ben Schwartz
5365 State Highway 145
Cobleskill N.Y. 12043
.

Binghamton Agway
145 Broad Avenue
Binghamton N.Y. 13904
607-723-7409

Blends Farm & Feed
7788 Route 49
Osceola P.A. 16942
607-382-5448

Botting’s Farm & Home
457 Martville Road
Martville N.Y. 13111
315-564-7476

Canal Street Hardware
3 South Canal Street
Oxford N.Y. 13830
607-843-6929

Cedar Lane Ag, LLC
26 Allis Ave
Moravia, N.Y. 13118
315-497-9657

Cochecton Mills
30 Depot Road
Cochecton N.Y. 12726
845-932-8282

Cougler Feeds LLC
88 Rensselaer St
Heuvelton N.Y. 13654
315-344-7061

Country Boy Hardware
2525 W Main St
Cato N.Y. 13033
315-626-6577

Deaton’s Agway
3952 Port St
Pulaski N.Y. 13142
315-298-2566

Dryden Agway
59 West Main Street
Dryden N.Y. 13053
607-844-8663

Eichers Sales & Service
554 River Rd
Clyde N.Y. 14433
.

Eli Hostetler
7857 St Rt 305
Belfast N.Y. 14711
585-968-9772

Endicott Agway
116 Jennings Street
Endicott N.Y. 13760
607-754-6660

Everything and a Little More
246 Bruce Porn Road
Grand Gorge, NY 12434
518-291-0147

Ezra J Yoder
231 Coveytown Rd
Constable N.Y. 12926
.

Fairbanks Stable
701 Bear Gulch Road
Richmondville N.Y. 12149
518-337-7362

Farm & Tool Line
682 Fordsbush Rd
Fort Plain, NY 13339
518-527-6838

Finger Lakes Dairy Services, Inc.
7474 Ross Road
Lowville, NY 13367
315-377-4000

Heps Builder's Bargain Outlet & Hardware
115 N Exchange St
Geneva N.Y. 14456
315-789-6944

Himrod Farm Supply
3141 Himrod Road
Himrod, NY 14842
315-531-9497

Hollenbeck’s Feed & Coal
5 Catatonk Lane
Owego N.Y.13827
607-687-2509

Homestead Coal Inc.
7147 SR 415
Bath, NY 14810
607-776-6703

Honey Hill Farm Store
198 Honey Hill Rd
Fulton, NY 13069
315-598-7332

Hoof N Paws Farm
5046 NY-28
Newport, NY 13416
315-717-6101

Ithaca Agway
213 South Fulton Street
Ithaca N.Y. 14850
607-272-1848

Jireh Organic Farms & Livestock of NY
375 Southline Road
Galway N.Y. 12074
207-577-4612

Joel Horst
12172 East Yates Center Rd
Lyndonville N.Y. 14098
585-332-4019

Little Falls Ace Hardware
441 West Main Street
Little Falls N.Y. 13365
315-508-5329

Locust Lane Feeds
2759 Highland Road
Marathon N.Y. 13803
.

Midlakes Sales LLC
6500 Log City Rd
Ovid, NY 14521
607-869-9483

Mills Farm Supply
5116 State Highway 41
Greene N.Y. 13778
607-656-4186

Mosie Shetler
10975 Rt. 26
Ava NY 13303
.

Nightingale True Value
4068 South Street
Marcellus N.Y. 13108
315-673-2001

Nightingale Tully Lakes
6 Elm Street
Tully N.Y. 13159
315-238-7050

Owego Agway
38 West Avenue
Owego N.Y. 13827
607-687-4115

Phelps Mercantile, Inc.
62 Ontario Street
Phelps N.Y. 14532
315-548-5231

Quackenbush Hardware
4777 NY-14A
Geneva, NY 14456
585-526-6988

R & M Farm & Pro Hardware
480 State Highway 11
Marathon N.Y. 13803
607-849-3291

Sam Yoder
5459 Knoxboro Rd
Munnsville N.Y. 13409
315-527-8871

Sodus Feeds & Needs
7639 Ridge Road
Sodus N.Y. 14551
315-553-2264

Southern Tier Hardware & Feed
103 E. Woodlawn Avenue
Elmira N.Y. 14901
607-733-7745

Tom’s Hardware & Feed, Inc.
615 Cayuta Avenue
Waverly N.Y. 14892
607-565-2736

Tylutki Family Farms
197 Caswell Rd
Palatine Bridge N.Y. 13428
518-848-7459

Warsaw North Country Ag LLC
6195 State Route 20 A
Warsaw NY 14569
585-969-7034

Windey Acres Tack Box
27 Minckler Rd
Mexico N.Y. 13114
315-963-7416

Winding Dale Farm
1226 County Rte 87
Mannsville N.Y. 13661
315-816-6294